35.1 C
Sunday, July 14, 2024

Karnataka HC stays FIR against ex-BJP minister


Share post:


Bengaluru: The Karnataka High Court on Tuesday ordered a temporary stay on an

FIR filed against former BJP minister Dr CN Ashwathnarayan booked for his remarks against Chief Minister Siddaramaiah during a rally ahead of state assembly election.

The Court stayed FIR against the petitioner for a period of four weeks.

Prima facie, Justice M Nagaprasanna, observed that there was no prima facie intent to cause riot via provocative remarks made by Dr Ashwathnarayan.

“What merits consideration now is whether the facts would meet the ingredients of Section 153 …

The result of the statement should be so provocative that it should result in rioting or is capable of resulting in rioting,” the court observed.

The FIR was registered on May 24 against Dr Ashwathnarayan’s remarks against Siddaramaiah in February. He was booked for offences under Sections 506 (criminal intimidation) and 153 (provocation with intent to cause riot) of the Indian Penal Code (IPC).

During the hearing, Dr Ashwathnarayan’s counsel Prabhuling Navadagi submitted that the defendant M Lakshmana was neither present when the remarks were being made, nor a visual and an audio recording was not produced before the Lordship.

“It is his version of what happened. There has to be prima facie material, something further,” he submitted.

Navadgi also argued that once a non-cognizable report was registered on an earlier complaint, a second complaint could not be registered.

The defendant’s arguments that the mind of the police changed to file a second complaint just because the government changed does not hold good, Dr Ashwathnarayan’s counsel.

Challenging the FIR, Dr Ashwathnarayan stated that his enthusiastic remarks were made during the election campaign to motivate his party workers.

“Narayan without the intention to cause any sort of injury (verbally or physically) to the then opposition leader in state, made the speech only with an intention to defeating another political rival in the elections and it was meant in a way of vanquishing an opponent by way of electoral poll,” the plea stated.

It was claimed that the complainant chose to act on the statement made in February within a few days of the new ruling party coming to power.

He also stated that the complainant was trying to cause disturbance by giving the political statement a ‘colour of enmity and hatred’ amongst the public.

Dr Ashwathnarayan further alleged that the complainant was only trying to capitalise on the electoral victory and get back at his political rivals.

Related articles

Vikravandi bypoll win will be etched in golden words in DMK’s history : Stalin

Chennai: Buoyed by the massive victory in the bypoll to the Vikravandi Assembly seat, Tamil Nadu Chief Minister...

KP Sharma Oli to be sworn in Nepal prime minister on Sunday

Kathmandu: Former Prime Minister and chairman of the CPN-UML party has staked his claim to the post of...

TMC Kalyani wins Raiganj assembly seat by-poll defeating BJP candidate

Kolkata: West Bengal ruling the Trinamool Congress' electoral juggernaut continued to reign for the past two decades in...

On ‘martyrs day’ J&K politicians put under ‘house arrest’, barred from visiting old city

Srinagar: Former chief minister Mehbooba Mufti and several political leaders in Jammu and Kashmir on Saturday claimed that...